A cry for help to create a fair transport sector

Last week, an employer sat in my office. Not a multinational, not a CEO with a detailed business plan, but a father and son who run a family transport company together.

A company with a little under fifty lorries. And yet this employer came to us, the union, with a cry for help.

He pleaded for action against social dumping in the transport sector. So, what about his own employers’ federation? Well, he had little faith in them. Too little decisiveness, too much resignation.
We should also be questioning the role of certain employers’ organisations, such as the IRU, which has no hesitation in supporting initiatives that try to “import” drivers from outside the EU, whereas everyone knows that this only increases social dumping.

This family business, which pays Belgian wages and complies with all the rules, finds itself losing contracts time and time again. Why? Because its fair prices make the company 30% more expensive than its unscrupulous competitors. Competitors that bring in drivers from Eastern Europe – or even people from other countries beyond that. These are transport companies that set up offices in countries such as Poland or Lithuania so that they can purchase lorries more cheaply – as well as benefit from subsidies and pay less tax. The result? Belgian companies are being priced out of the market.

This is by no means an isolated case. A few days later I received a similar cry for help, this time from one of the largest haulage companies in Belgium. It was a major player in the industry with hundreds of trucks and a flourishing logistics arm. Until now. Because they are also seeing their competitive edge being whittled away by social dumping. Until recently, they had been growing steadily. But now they are struggling because they continue applying Belgian wages and labour conditions. And so they are having a tough time in this race to the bottom that only benefits rogue companies. Names such as Waberer’s, Girteka and Hegelmann are being mentioned.
Just think about that for a moment. When honest employers come to the union with a cry for help, you know that the clocking is ticking and that it’s five minutes to midnight.

We can only continue to dream of an ideal world in which all of the transport companies in Belgium stick to the rules. A world in which the European Mobility Package is applied correctly. Where fair wages are paid and tax obligations properly complied with, as they should be. But that world will not happen if the government does not accept its responsibility.

That’s why we’re calling on the Belgian government to finally take action. Enforcement is the key. We need more inspectors and more inspections. Because, let’s be honest: there’s no lack of rules, there’s just a lack of willingness to enforce them.

What’s a simple solution? Bring in ten extra inspectors who will check the drivers of parked trucks every weekend for compliance with driving and rest times, as well as social legislation and labour regulations. The fines imposed have to be far more punitive, too. The companies breaking the rules are only too happy to pay the €1,500 fine for violating the long rest period for HGVs. Use modern methods: scan the data from tachographs and check on-board documents. That is not only perfectly achievable, but would also generate an enormous financial benefit. One inspection in Zeebrugge announced in advance yielded €250,000 in the space of just a day. Imagine what ten inspectors could produce every weekend! It would not only put money in the bank, but above all it would have a deterrent effect on social dumpers.

What do you think of the following proposal? Increase the fine for breaches of the long rest time spent aboard trucks to €15,000. Check 200 parked-up HGVs every weekend, knowing that at least 50% of them will be in breach of the rules. That would yield €1.5 million per weekend.

And if this money were to be used to support bona fide Belgian companies, we would also be giving a much-needed boost to our beleaguered transport sector.

And then there’s a second area of responsibility: that of the major haulage customers. IKEA, BMW, Unilever, Carrefour, Nike and co – how much longer can you stay silent? How long will you continue to turn a blind eye while subcontractors of subcontractors of subcontractors flout the rules in your supply chain? The drivers’ strike in Gräfenhausen only served to make this painfully clear: things have gone beyond social fraud. This is exploitation. This is modern slavery.

A fair and honest transport sector can only exist if all of the links in the chain accept their responsibility: government, employers and customers.

Right now, we are seeing the haulage industry in free-fall. It’s a sector where well-trained, properly qualified drivers are disappearing and being replaced by people who barely know how to load and unload their truck properly. People who walk around in worn-out trainers, without safety equipment, without knowledge of the rules and often even without knowledge of the language. People who are not only being exploited, but who also present a danger on our roads.

Come on, Belgium, accept your responsibility! The time for talking is over. It’s time for action!

 

Frank Moreels
President BTB